Earn-Outs in Business Sales: Carrot or Stick?

When selling a business, one of the most debated topics is the earn-out. Love them or hate them, they remain a common feature of SME business sales and M&A transactions.

For many owners, especially those approaching retirement, understanding earn-outs is critical. After years of building value, the last thing you want is to walk into a deal that leaves you short-changed. At BusinessExits.co.uk, we specialise in helping retirement-focused business owners navigate these challenges and exit on their terms.

Handled poorly, earn-outs can feel like a stick, making you “earn” what you’ve already delivered. Structured correctly, they can be a carrot, helping bridge gaps, reward future performance, and secure a fair exit value for both buyer and seller.

What Is an Earn-Out?

An earn-out is a performance-based element of consideration in a business sale. Rather than paying the entire purchase price upfront, the buyer agrees to pay part of it later, provided the business meets agreed performance targets.

Earn-outs are typically used to:

• Bridge a valuation gap where the seller sees growth potential but the buyer is cautious.

• Motivate sellers who remain involved post-completion to keep driving performance.

• Protect buyers from overpaying if forecasts don’t materialise.

When Earn-Outs Work

Earn-outs can add real value if the circumstances are right:

• You remain involved: You’ll still be in the business and able to influence results.

• Growth is tangible: A strong pipeline, new contracts, or new markets are on the horizon.

• Metrics are clear: Simple, auditable KPIs like EBITDA or gross profit, with safeguards.

• Buyer continuity: No major changes in pricing, staff, or operations that undermine the targets.

• 
  

In these cases, the earn-out becomes the icing on the cake, not the cake itself.

When to Walk Away

Earn-outs aren’t always appropriate. Warning signs include:

• You want a clean exit: If you’re retiring immediately, you won’t control performance.

• Buyer holds all the levers: Integration, resourcing, or pricing decisions sit outside your influence.

• Volatile revenues: Reliance on a handful of clients or unpredictable markets.

• Over-weighted earn-out: If deferred consideration is the bulk of the deal, your retirement security is at risk.

• 
  

In short: if it feels more like a stick than a carrot, the structure is wrong.

How to Structure an Earn-Out That Works

A balanced earn-out should be fair, clear, and limited. Consider these principles:

• Keep it small: Earn-out should be a minority of the deal value.

• Define the maths: Agree KPIs and calculation methods upfront.

• Protect against manipulation: Lock accounting policies and central cost treatments.

• Governance matters: Set monthly reporting, system access, and audit rights.

• Separate roles: Keep employment terms separate from sale consideration.

• Dispute resolution: Agree mechanisms to resolve issues early.

The Bottom Line

An earn-out should be a carrot to help you and the buyer meet in the middle, rewarding future value, not a stick that risks undermining your retirement.

If you’re approaching retirement, this is especially important. After decades of work, your exit needs to protect your legacy, your people, and your future security. That’s why at BusinessExits.co.uk, we position ourselves as the champion of retirement business sales.

We ensure every deal structure, including earn-outs, is designed to give you confidence, clarity, and control.

Ready to plan your retirement exit? Contact us today and book a confidential discussion. It’s the first step towards securing a fair deal and the retirement you deserve.

Contact Us